Paparella was horrified. “I realized, they don’t want me to think. After that, I just didn’t see how faith and women’s empowerment could be reconciled.”
This quote comes from a post entitled, “I believe you”: The Silence and the Shame of Sexual Violence in the Church, by Catherine Woodiwiss. It reflects on how campus leaders and student Christian leaders’ masculinised view of God gave them little understanding of women’s points of view within the church.
What is it about the misogyny of the church? Why is still ruled by the boys when most of its members are women? Why does patriarchy seem to persevere longer in the church than in society? Is it based on such verses as Gen 3:16? …
16 To the woman he said,
“I will make your pains in childbearing very severe;
with painful labor you will give birth to children.
Your desire will be for your husband,
and he will rule over you.”
It is somewhat unsettling that some take this verse, and similar others, as prescription for how women might be treated. It’s unsettling because it reflects a view of God as domineering and lacking in compassion. It’s unsettling that some readers of this blog take an anti-intellectual view and insist on using the hermeneutics of “it says it in the Bible so it must be true”. It’s unsettling that the heritage of Luther and The Confessions is boiled down to proof texts. It’s unsettling that a panorama of theologians in the last century is dismissed in favour of the most basic, simplistic tool.
We don’t believe that many people hold that view of God.
It does however make sense to view this verse as sin being enacted, rather than God’s prescription for relationships. Ruling over another person may be the language of empires, but it is not the language of relationships.
If the Church is unable to accommodate a view of women as gifted, enabled, empowered, equal and pastoral, then the Church is not a safe place for women. Under such circumstances we could not encourage women (or those supporting them) attend LCA congregations.
For the LCA to have a future there is no alternative but absolute equality for women and men.
While this, no doubt, is shocking for some who correspondent with this blog, living with diversity should only be as shocking as visiting the local bank, supermarket, school, accountant, music shop, opticians…, for diversity in Australia’s cities and towns is a reality which is never to be reversed. No congregation should ever be forced to call a woman and no congregation should ever be forced to call a man.
- Are Women Really Saved through Childbearing? (christianitytoday.com)
- Looking Under the Skirts of Theology: Roman Catholic and Mormon Women Team Up in Support of Women Priests (prweb.com)
- Can a Woman be a Youth Pastor? (youthmin.org)
- Street Art Collective “Women on Walls” Fights for Female Empowerment in Egypt (complex.com)